When Supernatural Fear Gripped the Maldives

Introduction

The evidence therefore calls for caution. Belief in harmful magic is not itself mass hysteria, and traditional ritual practice should not automatically be treated as fraud or deviance. The important question is what happens when misfortune is attributed to a hidden supernatural agent and the search for that agent becomes a social or political campaign. Cases involving allegedly possessed children in 2013, clusters of sorcery arrests in 2016, an abuse investigation linked to exorcism in 2020 and allegations against a government minister in 2024 show how fear can spread even when proof of supernatural harm is impossible to establish.[maldivesindependent.com]maldivesindependent.compolice conduct witch hunt on thakandhoo 65383Maldives IndependentPolice conduct witch hunt on Thakandhoo after children…September 12, 2013 — Police conduct witch hunt on Thakandho…Published: September 12, 2013

Why sorcery fears have deep roots

Maldivian oral tradition contains a crowded supernatural world of dangerous spirits, sea monsters, unexplained illnesses and specialist practitioners believed capable of protecting communities. A scholarly review of Xavier Romero-Frias’s collected Maldivian folktales notes that stories about spirits and magic frequently connect disease and death with threatening supernatural beings. In the traditional tales, however, the knowledgeable ritual specialist is often a defender who confronts danger rather than a sinister outsider conspiring against society.[IUScholarWorks]scholarworks.iu.eduScholarWorksReview of Xavier Romero-Frias, Folk Tales of the Maldivesby EM Knoll · 2013 — 1) Tales of spirits and monsters provides ins…

This distinction matters because modern reporting often compresses several different ideas into the English expression “black magic”. Anthropologist Fathimath Azra Ahmed argues that Maldivians distinguish between practices understood as potentially productive or protective and those regarded as destructive. Her research treats accusations of sorcery not merely as survivals of folklore but as ways of expressing social tension, bodily distress and political criticism. A ritual object, prayer book or unexplained illness may therefore carry very different meanings for believers, sceptics, police officers and journalists.[scarab.bates.edu]scarab.bates.eduThese practices may loosely be categorized in Englishfanditha and sihuru: Social and Political Import of Muslim…by FA Ahmed · 2017 — Muslim-dhivehi inhabitants of the Maldives bold indig…

The supernatural traditions of the islands have also been reinterpreted within an exclusively Muslim national framework. The 2008 Constitution identifies Islam as a basis of the state, while laws protect what officials call religious unity and restrict the public propagation of other religions. This does not mean that every Maldivian holds the same beliefs. It does mean that arguments about legitimate healing, forbidden sorcery, possession and religious authority take place in a legally and politically sensitive environment.[U.S. Department of State]2021-2025.state.govOpen source on state.gov.

The 2013 Thakandhoo possession scare

One of the clearest examples of a local supernatural fear turning into collective action occurred on Thakandhoo, an island in northern Haa Alif Atoll, in September 2013. Four children living in the same household were reportedly believed to be possessed by evil spirits. Ritual practitioners were brought to the island to recite Quranic passages, while residents searched for an explanation and directed suspicion towards someone allegedly responsible for causing the affliction.[minivannewsarchive.com]minivannewsarchive.compolice conduct witch hunt on thakandhoo 65383police conduct witch hunt on thakandhoo 65383

The episode escalated beyond family treatment. According to contemporary reporting, the island council wanted the source of the supposed magic identified, police became involved and homes were searched for suspicious objects. The language of a “witch hunt” used in the press captured the accusatory atmosphere, although the event was not a witch trial in the historical European sense. There was no public proof that any person had caused the children’s condition through supernatural means.[minivannewsarchive.com]minivannewsarchive.compolice conduct witch hunt on thakandhoo 65383police conduct witch hunt on thakandhoo 65383

Nor is there enough clinical evidence to diagnose the incident retrospectively as mass psychogenic illness. Such a diagnosis normally requires a recognisable pattern of symptoms spreading through a socially connected group, accompanied by medical investigation that fails to identify a sufficient physical cause. The available Thakandhoo reporting describes belief in possession and a community search for a culprit, but it does not provide medical examinations, symptom histories or an epidemiological investigation. Calling it “mass hysteria” would therefore claim more than the evidence permits.

A better description is a possession scare with elements of rumour contagion. Distress affecting several children was interpreted through a familiar supernatural model. Ritual intervention then gave that interpretation public authority, while searches and accusations widened the event from a health or family problem into a community crisis. This pattern resembles school-possession panics elsewhere in South and South-East Asia, but the Thakandhoo case is too poorly documented to establish the same psychological mechanism.

Arrest waves and the problem of proving magic

Sorcery accusations continued to produce police action after Thakandhoo. In January 2016, the Maldives Independent reported that seven people had been arrested in separate cases over roughly two weeks. Police said they had recovered materials associated with harmful magic. Relatives disputed some of these interpretations, saying that items described as sorcery equipment included ordinary Arabic religious books.[Maldives Independent]maldivesindependent.commaldives sees wave of arrests on sorcery charges 121826Another four were arrested last…

That disagreement exposes the central evidential problem. Police may be able to prove possession of an object, threats, deception, unlawful entry, poisoning or assault. They cannot demonstrate through ordinary forensic methods that a ritual caused illness, changed an election result or placed a supernatural curse on someone. Objects become incriminating largely because investigators and communities already agree on what they supposedly signify.

The legal position has also been unclear. Reporting in 2017 stated that the modern Maldivian Penal Code did not contain a specific offence of sorcery, creating difficulties in deciding how suspected practitioners should be prosecuted. Suspects were sometimes detained and later released because investigators could not translate allegations of supernatural causation into a sustainable criminal charge.[Maldives Independent]maldivesindependent.comMaldives Independent Maldives' anti-black magic legal measures needMaldives Independent Maldives' anti-black magic legal measures need

This uncertainty can encourage repeated arrest-and-release cycles. Detention reassures frightened residents that authorities are taking the accusation seriously, but a later release may fail to change the underlying belief. Believers can interpret the absence of a conviction not as evidence against the allegation but as proof that the law is incapable of dealing with invisible harm. The result is a scare that may persist socially even when it collapses legally.

When sorcery allegations enter politics

Claims about magic have occasionally been attached to electoral competition. In August 2018, four men were reportedly arrested on suspicion of using sorcery in an attempt to help the Maldivian Democratic Party win that year’s presidential election. The accusation placed an invisible supernatural struggle alongside an already intense contest for political power.[Maldives Independent]maldivesindependent.comOpen source on maldivesindependent.com.

Election-related sorcery stories are socially useful because they turn uncertain political outcomes into intentional acts by hidden enemies. Victory or defeat no longer depends only on campaigning, institutions, public opinion or chance. It can be blamed on secret ritual interference. Such claims are difficult to disprove because the proposed mechanism is invisible, while almost any unusual object or private meeting can be absorbed into the story.

The most internationally reported episode came in June 2024, when environment minister Fathimath Shamnaz Ali Saleem was detained. Maldivian media reports, repeated by international news organisations, alleged that the case involved an attempt to use “black magic” against President Mohamed Muizzu. Police confirmed her arrest but did not publicly establish the more dramatic supernatural claim as fact. She was released in July after spending several weeks in custody.[South China Morning Post]scmp.comOpen source on scmp.com.

This distinction was often lost in headlines. “Minister arrested in black-magic case” is supportable as a description of the allegation surrounding the detention. “Minister performed black magic on the president” would state an unproven claim as fact. The public record available in English does not demonstrate that a ritual was performed, that it was directed at the president or that it produced any effect.

The incident nevertheless shows why sorcery scares remain politically powerful. The accused was not a marginal religious leader but a state official. The alleged target was the president. Those positions transformed a difficult-to-verify criminal investigation into a story about betrayal at the centre of government. International coverage then amplified the most exotic element while offering comparatively little detail about evidence, charges or the eventual release.

Exorcism, healing and the risk of abuse

Belief in possession can also create opportunities for coercion when a supposed healer claims exclusive power over a vulnerable person. In November 2020, Maldivian police arrested two men following allegations that a woman and her three daughters had been confined and subjected to psychological, physical and sexual abuse under the pretext of religious exorcism. The Criminal Court later ordered one suspect detained pending trial.[The Edition]edition.mvThe EditionPolice make 2 arrests over 'Ruqya' multiple-abuse case26 Nov 2020 — Two local males, aged 24 and 39, were arrested over allega…

The central issue in such a case is not whether a reader accepts or rejects belief in spirits. It is whether claims of spiritual authority are used to isolate people, override consent, prevent medical care or conceal violence. A religiously framed healing practice may be experienced by participants as comforting and legitimate. It becomes a safeguarding matter when a practitioner uses fear of possession to secure obedience or unrestricted access to a victim.

This is also why the loose label “cult” is unhelpful. The reported 2020 case concerned alleged abuse by individuals operating through an exorcism claim, not necessarily a stable organisation with members, doctrine and a charismatic leader. Describing every abusive healer as a cult leader can obscure the actual mechanisms involved: family trust, fear of supernatural retaliation, dependency, secrecy and the belief that ordinary authorities cannot understand the danger.

Mental-health research on spirit possession further warns against treating believers with ridicule. People may use spiritual and medical explanations at the same time, and symptoms attributed to possession can have psychological, neurological, physical or social causes. Responsible care requires assessment of all these possibilities while protecting the person from harmful treatment. Dismissing the belief entirely may drive a distressed family towards secretive practitioners; accepting every supernatural claim may delay necessary healthcare.[ResearchGate]researchgate.netResearch Gate(PDF) Evil Eye, Jinn Possession, and Mental Health IssuesResearch Gate(PDF) Evil Eye, Jinn Possession, and Mental Health Issues

Moral panic or genuine social problem?

The Maldivian cases combine several phenomena that should be kept separate.

Traditional belief refers to inherited ideas about spirits, harmful ritual and protective practice. These beliefs are culturally meaningful and do not automatically produce panic or harm.

Rumour contagion occurs when an uncertain allegation passes between families, islands, news outlets or political networks, gathering detail and apparent credibility through repetition.

Moral panic begins when a person or practice is portrayed as a grave threat to the community’s values and institutions, especially when the scale of the danger exceeds the available evidence. Political sorcery stories can take this form because they depict secret practitioners as enemies of both religion and the state.

Persecution occurs when accusation itself becomes enough to justify searches, humiliation, detention or violence. Sorcery allegations are particularly dangerous because innocence is difficult to prove: denial may be interpreted as deception, while ordinary books and personal objects can be reclassified as occult evidence.

Criminal abuse is different again. Confinement, sexual assault, threats and financial exploitation remain real offences even when they are committed within a supernatural or religious narrative. Rejecting an allegation of magical causation should never mean ignoring evidence of ordinary human harm.

The Maldives has not experienced a documented national sorcery panic on the scale of an early-modern witch hunt. What it has experienced is a recurring readiness for supernatural accusations to enter policing, politics and intimate life. The pattern is episodic rather than continuous, but each revival draws credibility from older stories and earlier arrests.

Why these scares spread

The geography of the Maldives helps explain the social force of local accusations. The country consists of dispersed island communities in which family relationships, reputation and local authority can be unusually visible. In a small community, several unexplained illnesses or behavioural changes may quickly become common knowledge. The same closeness that allows neighbours to provide help can also accelerate suspicion.

Sorcery offers an intentional explanation for events that otherwise feel random. Illness, conflict, romantic rejection, professional failure and political defeat become the work of an identifiable enemy. This can be psychologically attractive because it replaces uncertainty with a story containing a cause, culprit and remedy.

Authority figures may then reinforce the interpretation. A ritual practitioner can identify signs of possession; a council can demand investigation; police can confiscate objects; journalists can repeat the allegation; politicians can exploit it. Each institution appears to confirm the one before it, even though none has independently established supernatural causation.

Digital and international media add another layer. Local reports may contain cautious wording, legal uncertainty and competing testimony. International headlines tend to retain the phrases “black magic”, “curse” and “president” because they are instantly dramatic. The resulting coverage can make a disputed allegation appear to be an established feature of Maldivian public life rather than a contested claim arising from a particular investigation.

What the record does not show

There is no strong accessible evidence that the Maldives has produced a large, organised apocalyptic sect, UFO religion or millenarian movement comparable with the best-known cases elsewhere. Nor do the available sources establish a classic nationwide outbreak of contagious fainting, dancing, laughing or medically unexplained illness.

This absence may partly reflect gaps in documentation. Reporting from smaller islands is uneven, older records are limited and much local discussion is not available in English. Yet missing evidence should not be replaced with speculation. Folktales about spirits are not records of literal historical attacks, and modern possession claims cannot be retroactively diagnosed without medical data.

The same caution applies to the word “cult”. Religious conformity in the Maldives has generated serious disputes about dissent, extremism and freedom of belief, but those issues are not automatically cult history. A minority religious view, an informal healing circle and an abusive closed group are different social formations. Hostile labelling can itself become part of a moral panic by presenting unfamiliar or unpopular belief as proof of organised danger.

The lasting significance

The most important Maldivian pattern is not a single spectacular episode. It is the repeated movement of supernatural suspicion across boundaries: from folklore into explanations of illness, from private conflict into community accusation, from ritual healing into alleged abuse, and from political rivalry into police investigation.

These cases reveal the practical difficulty of governing claims that are socially powerful but empirically untestable. Authorities cannot prove that magic caused an event, yet ignoring frightened communities may deepen distrust. Arresting alleged practitioners may calm an immediate crisis, but it can also legitimise the premise that supernatural attacks are a matter for criminal investigation.

A more protective response would concentrate on demonstrable conduct: threats, coercion, fraud, assault, unlawful confinement, poisoning, exploitation and interference with medical care. It would also protect accused people from punishment based only on reputation or ambiguous possessions. Public communication should distinguish clearly between an allegation, evidence of a ritual act and evidence that an ordinary crime occurred.

The Maldives therefore belongs in the wider history of panics and contagious belief not because it offers a simple tale of irrational crowds, but because it shows how inherited supernatural ideas can become tools for explaining distress and assigning blame. The lesson is less about whether magic is “really believed” than about what institutions and communities do once belief turns into an accusation.

Amazon book picks

Further Reading

Books and field guides related to When Supernatural Fear Gripped the Maldives. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.

Book

The Demon-Haunted World

By Carl Sagan

Explores belief, evidence and extraordinary claims.

See on Amazon

Book

The Varieties of Religious Experience

By William James, Dr. William James et al.

First published 1817. Subjects: Religious Psychology, Religion, Conversion, Experience (Religion), Philosophy and religion.

See on Amazon

Book

Magic, witchcraft, and religion

By Pamela Moro, James Myers et al.

First published 2006. Subjects: Religion, Occultism.

See on Amazon

Book

The Maldives

By J.J. Robinson

First published 2016. Subjects: Democracy, Maldives, Politics and government, Social conditions, Islam.

See on Amazon

Browse more on Amazon:The Demon Haunted WorldThe Varieties of Religious ExperienceMagic, witchcraft, and religion

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Endnotes

1. Source: edition.mv
Link:https://edition.mv/news/20611

2. Source: scarab.bates.edu
Title: These practices may loosely be categorized in English
Link:https://scarab.bates.edu/honorstheses/192/

3. Source: 2021-2025.state.gov
Link:https://2021-2025.state.gov/reports/2023-report-on-international-religious-freedom/maldives/

4. Source: minivannewsarchive.com
Title: police conduct witch hunt on thakandhoo 65383
Link:https://minivannewsarchive.com/politics/police-conduct-witch-hunt-on-thakandhoo-65383

5. Source: researchgate.net
Title: Research Gate(PDF) Evil Eye, Jinn Possession, and Mental Health Issues
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328124453_Evil_Eye_Jinn_Possession_and_Mental_Health_Issues_An_Islamic_Perspective

6. Source: researchgate.net
Title: Deconstructing a Modern Witch Hunt Satanic Cults Ritual Abuse and Moral Panic
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Stuart-Wright-4/publication/292145151_Deconstructing_a_Modern_Witch_Hunt_Satanic_Cults_Ritual_Abuse_and_Moral_Panic/links/5734d05208ae298602deed3e/Deconstructing-a-Modern-Witch-Hunt-Satanic-Cults-Ritual-Abuse-and-Moral-Panic.pdf

7. Source: researchgate.net
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/390822121_PROOF_OF_THE_CRIME_OF_SUPERNATURAL_POWERS_IN_LAW_NUMBER_1_OF_2023_AS_A_LEGACY_OF_THE_WETBOEK_VAN_STRAFRECHT

8. Source: researchgate.net
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/289784863_Witchcraft_Sorcery_Rumors_and_Gossip

9. Source: minivannewsarchive.com
Link:https://minivannewsarchive.com/tag/black-magic

10. Source: maldivesindependent.com
Title: police conduct witch hunt on thakandhoo 65383
Link:https://maldivesindependent.com/politics/police-conduct-witch-hunt-on-thakandhoo-65383

Published: September 12, 2013

11. Source: maldivesindependent.com
Title: maldives sees wave of arrests on sorcery charges 121826
Link:https://maldivesindependent.com/society/maldives-sees-wave-of-arrests-on-sorcery-charges-121826

12. Source: channelstv.com
Title: maldives climate minister released in black magic case
Link:https://www.channelstv.com/2024/07/13/maldives-climate-minister-released-in-black-magic-case/

13. Source: scholarworks.iu.edu
Link:https://scholarworks.iu.edu/journals/index.php/jfrr/article/view/38938

14. Source: maldivesindependent.com
Title: Maldives Independent Maldives’ anti-black magic legal measures need ‘
Link:https://maldivesindependent.com/society/maldives-anti-black-magic-legal-measures-need-streamlining-132875

15. Source: maldivesindependent.com
Link:https://maldivesindependent.com/black-magic

16. Source: scmp.com
Link:https://www.scmp.com/news/asia/south-asia/article/3268264/maldives-minister-arrested-performing-black-magic-president-muizzu

17. Source: Wikipedia
Title: Mass psychogenic illness
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_psychogenic_illness

18. Source: maldivesindependent.com
Link:https://maldivesindependent.com/penal-code

19. Source: maldivesindependent.com
Title: apostates jihadists and extremists face tough new punishments 137396
Link:https://maldivesindependent.com/society/apostates-jihadists-and-extremists-face-tough-new-punishments-137396

Additional References

20. Source: iias.asia
Link:https://www.iias.asia/the-review/folk-tales-maldives

21. Source: youtube.com
Title: Maldives Minister Arrested For Performing ‘Black Magic’ On President Muizzu
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHoI23ikoZc

22. Source: youtube.com
Title: Maldives’ Climate Minister Arrested for ‘Black Magic’ on President
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gHMxanFHKY

23. Source: youtube.com
Title: Maldivian Ministers Arrested for Black Magic on President Muizzu
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5bnUrn8UNWA

24. Source: youtube.com
Title: Maldives Police Arrest 2 Sitting Ministers Over Black Magic Charges
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CurGFVOGPwY

25. Source: academia.edu
Link:https://www.academia.edu/4677829/Folk_Tales_of_the_Maldives

26. Source: academia.edu
Link:https://www.academia.edu/24691633/Spirit_Possession_and_the_Goddess_Ishtar_in_Ancient_Mesopotamia

27. Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/channelsforum/posts/a-former-maldives-climate-change-minister-detained-last-month-on-allegations-she/1128117112009372/

28. Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/mountainbeacon2600/photos/bontoc-school-explains-student-incident-as-no-demons-just-distressby-frank-cimat/122252269916122796/

29. Source: scribd.com
Link:https://www.scribd.com/document/452332721/Folk-Tales-of-the-Maldives