When Belief and Fear Became Public Threats

Introduction

Four cases are particularly revealing. The 2007 battle near Najaf involved an armed movement described as apocalyptic, although official accounts of its identity and intentions were contradictory. In 2012, an “emo” scare helped create an atmosphere of terror around young people whose clothes, music or perceived sexuality marked them as outsiders. More recently, Iraqi authorities have arrested members of a small sacrificial-suicide movement known as Qurban. Meanwhile, Sabean-Mandaeans continue to face damaging stereotypes linking their religion with witchcraft. Together, these episodes show how insecurity, sectarian politics, media amplification and hostile labelling can turn unfamiliar beliefs or appearances into public threats.

What counts as a panic in Iraq?

Several different phenomena are often bundled together under words such as “cult”, “panic” or “hysteria”, but they should be separated.

A millenarian movement expects a dramatic transformation of the world, often involving divine intervention, a returning saviour or a final battle. Such beliefs are not automatically violent. They become a public-security issue only when leaders connect prophecy to coercion, armed action or self-destruction.

A moral panic occurs when a person, group or cultural habit is portrayed as a grave threat to society, often far beyond the available evidence. Public officials, religious figures, media organisations and rumours may reinforce one another until punishment seems urgent.

A witchcraft accusation attributes misfortune to hidden supernatural action. It may be an honestly held belief, a form of fraud, a way of explaining illness or family conflict, or a weapon used to stigmatise an unwanted neighbour or minority.

Mass psychogenic illness, formerly called mass hysteria, is narrower still. It describes genuine physical symptoms spreading through a group without an identified toxic or infectious cause, usually in a setting of intense anxiety. Although such incidents are well documented in schools and workplaces elsewhere, Iraq’s best-evidenced collective-belief episodes do not fit that pattern. Applying the term casually to political violence, minority persecution or religious mobilisation would obscure more than it explains.

Ancient Mesopotamia feared harmful magic, but it was not a continuous witch hunt

The territory of modern Iraq contains the remains of societies in which magic was a normal part of religion, medicine and government. Ancient Mesopotamians did not treat every ritual act as sinister. Authorised specialists used incantations, figurines, purification and other ceremonies to protect people from illness, ghosts, curses and alleged hostile magic. Large collections of surviving tablets prescribe treatments for suffering believed to have been caused by witchcraft and distinguish these protective rites from illegitimate, harmful acts.[upenn.edu]oracc.museum.upenn.educmawroView text, 3.8, Ritual against the witchcraft of an adversary, slander and divine wrath; View text, 3.9, Cures against witchc…

This distinction matters because ancient Mesopotamia did not experience a European-style early modern witch craze in which thousands of people were prosecuted through a continent-wide judicial pattern. The evidence instead consists largely of ritual texts, legal concepts and stereotyped supernatural enemies. Scholarly work on these texts shows that the imagined witch was often female, while accusations could also be directed at male legal adversaries or foreign enemies of the king. Witchcraft language therefore expressed personal conflict, political hostility and fear of unexplained suffering as well as belief in supernatural attack.[Brill]brill.com1. ancient mesopotamian witchcraft beliefsIn all cases so far known, the accused persons are women, a fact that agrees with the pri…

There is also no simple unbroken line from ancient tablets to present-day Iraqi practice. Modern Iraqis live within very different religious, legal and social worlds. The ancient material is culturally important because it demonstrates how long people in the region have distinguished legitimate healing or protection from feared secret harm—not because contemporary accusations are unchanged survivals from Babylonian times.

The Soldiers of Heaven and the disputed battle near Najaf

On 28 January 2007, during the Iraq War and shortly before major religious commemorations in Najaf, Iraqi forces encountered a heavily armed community at Zarqa, north-east of the city. The fighting expanded into a major battle involving Iraqi troops and United States air and ground support. Hundreds of members of the encampment were reported killed or captured, and a United States helicopter was shot down. Contemporary Iraqi officials described the opponents as the Soldiers of Heaven, a messianic movement allegedly planning to attack senior clerics and pilgrims.[latimes.com]latimes.comLos Angeles Times Religious cult targeted in fierce battle near NajafLos Angeles TimesReligious cult targeted in fierce battle near NajafJanuary 30, 2007 — 30 Jan 2007 — By striking preemptively, Iraqi secu…Published: January 30, 2007

According to the official version, the group expected an imminent transformation associated with the return of a divinely guided redeemer and believed that conflict in Najaf could advance that process. Reports described its followers as living with families in an organised compound containing homes, weapons and a religious school. This combination of communal separation, charismatic authority, apocalyptic expectation and military preparation led journalists and analysts to call it a “cult”.[Time]time.comhow a cult grew in najafhow a cult grew in najaf

Yet the label should be used cautiously because basic facts remained contested. Iraqi officials gave inconsistent names for the leader, disagreed about whether the movement was connected to other religious claimants and alleged links with former regime personnel or Sunni extremists that observers found difficult to reconcile. Some accounts suggested a planned massacre of clerics; others raised the possibility that a confrontation at a checkpoint escalated into a much larger fight involving local tribespeople and pilgrims. Much of the early information came from officials directly involved in the operation, while independent access to the battlefield was limited.[Wikipedia]WikipediaSoldiers of HeavenSoldiers of Heaven

The safest conclusion is that an armed, heterodox messianic group was present and that a large battle unquestionably occurred. The precise membership of the force, the intentions of everyone in the compound and the details of the alleged assassination plot are less certain. The episode is therefore both a case of genuine millenarian mobilisation and a warning about how quickly wartime authorities and media can construct a neat “fanatical cult” narrative around a confused battlefield.

The wider setting helps explain why such movements could gain followers. By 2007, Iraq had endured invasion, state collapse, sectarian killing, unemployment and mass displacement. In that environment, prophecy could offer an explanation for chaos, a promise that humiliation would soon end and a role for otherwise powerless individuals in a world-changing drama. Those pressures do not make believers irrational; they show why apocalyptic ideas can become politically potent during prolonged crisis.

How apocalyptic language strengthened the Islamic State

The Islamic State was not merely a rumour or imagined menace. It was an organised armed movement that captured territory, governed populations through terror and committed mass atrocities. Nevertheless, apocalyptic belief formed an important part of its propaganda and helps explain how it presented an Iraqi and Syrian war as a cosmic event.

The group’s roots lay in the insurgent organisations that developed after the 2003 invasion and later became the Islamic State of Iraq. Its propagandists drew on end-times traditions, portraying contemporary battles as fulfilments of prophecy and followers as participants in the final struggle between truth and falsehood. Analysts of militant apocalypticism have noted that Iraq became a central symbolic landscape in such narratives, while later Islamic State propaganda connected territorial expansion with an approaching final confrontation.[Combating Terrorism Center at West Point]ctc.westpoint.eduOpen source on westpoint.edu.

Apocalyptic language served practical purposes. It made battlefield setbacks seem temporary, turned death into evidence of spiritual success and encouraged recruits to believe they had joined history’s decisive generation. Research into online support for the Islamic State also found that frustration with failed political uprisings and perceived political dead ends distinguished many supporters from opponents. That suggests prophecy worked alongside anger, exclusion and disappointment rather than replacing ordinary political motives.[arXiv]arxiv.orgarXiv#Failed Revolutions: Using Twitter to Study the Antecedents of ISIS SupportarXiv#Failed Revolutions: Using Twitter to Study the Antecedents of ISIS Support

Describing the Islamic State simply as a “death cult” may capture its brutality but provides a poor explanation. The organisation combined theology with military expertise, policing, taxation, media production and exploitation of sectarian grievances. Its apocalyptic claims were neither meaningless madness nor the sole cause of its violence. They were a powerful narrative layered onto the concrete conditions created by dictatorship, invasion, insurgency and communal conflict.

The 2012 “emo” scare turned youth culture into a threat

In early 2012, reports spread through Baghdad that teenagers and young adults identified as “emo” were being threatened, abducted or killed. The word referred loosely to a music-linked fashion involving distinctive hair, dark clothing and accessories, but in Iraqi public discussion it became entangled with accusations of homosexuality, Western decadence and devil worship.

The scare did not arise solely from neighbourhood gossip. Iraq’s Interior Ministry publicly condemned young people wearing tight clothes, skull imagery and facial jewellery, describing the style as a dangerous phenomenon that should be eliminated. Threatening leaflets reportedly appeared in Baghdad neighbourhoods, while media reports and rights organisations documented widespread fear among young people who believed their appearance or perceived sexuality could make them targets.[amnesty.org]amnesty.orgInternational Iraq: Investigate 'Emo' AttacksInternational Iraq: Investigate 'Emo' Attacks

The exact death toll was disputed. Reports ranged from a small number of confirmed killings to claims that dozens had died, and Iraqi officials denied that an organised nationwide murder campaign existed. That uncertainty should not be mistaken for proof that nothing happened. Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and the International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission reported a targeted campaign of intimidation and violence and called for an official investigation. The best-supported account is therefore not a single, clearly documented massacre with a settled victim count, but a real climate of threats and attacks intensified by poorly verified casualty claims.[Amnesty International]amnesty.orgInternational Iraq: Investigate 'Emo' AttacksInternational Iraq: Investigate 'Emo' Attacks

This was a classic moral-panic mechanism. A small and loosely defined youth style was treated as evidence of a hidden moral conspiracy. Symbols such as dark clothes and skulls became signs of Satanism; gender nonconformity became proof of sexual deviance; and rumours of killing increased fear even when individual cases were difficult to verify. The category “emo” widened until it could encompass gay men, fashionable teenagers and almost anyone judged insufficiently masculine or socially conventional.

The episode also demonstrates that panic and persecution can coexist. Some reports were exaggerated or confused, but the anxiety experienced by targeted young people was not imaginary. Once officials publicly classified a youth subculture as dangerous, armed groups and vigilantes could present harassment as moral protection. The most serious harm came not from the clothing or music but from the social permission created to punish people associated with them.

Qurban and the appeal of sacrificial suicide

From 2023 onwards, Iraqi security agencies reported arrests connected with a small movement commonly called Qurban or the Allahiyah movement. Accounts from southern Iraq described a ritual in which members drew lots or selected candles, with the chosen participant expected to die by strangulation as a sacrifice expressing devotion to Imam Ali. Iraqi officials linked the movement to a series of suicides and arrested dozens of alleged members in several provinces during 2024.[middleeasteye.net]middleeasteye.netiraq cracks down lottery based suicide cult has seen dozens deathsiraq cracks down lottery based suicide cult has seen dozens deaths

The available evidence is more substantial than a purely invented cult scare: arrests occurred, authorities identified suspected organisers, and court proceedings have since addressed allegations of coercing people into suicide. In May 2026, a Najaf court reportedly sentenced two men to six years’ imprisonment under provisions concerning the encouragement or assistance of suicide.[964media]en.964media.comCourt sentences two men for membership in secretiveCourt sentences two men for membership in secretive

Even so, dramatic descriptions such as “suicide cult sweeping the Middle East” can overstate the group’s reach. Public reporting depends heavily on security sources, and reliable information about membership, internal theology and the number of deaths remains limited. Claims that every follower was forcibly controlled, or that the movement represented a broad generational trend, require more evidence than is currently public.

Commentators have connected Qurban’s appeal to unemployment, political neglect and the search for meaning among young people in southern Iraq. That explanation is plausible but should not be reduced to poverty alone. Small sacrificial movements can attract people through friendship networks, online material, charismatic leadership, intense religious emotion and the promise of belonging to an elect community. Economic frustration may create vulnerability, but it does not mechanically produce an apocalyptic sect.[Middle East Eye]middleeasteye.netiraq cracks down lottery based suicide cult has seen dozens deathsiraq cracks down lottery based suicide cult has seen dozens deaths

The state response has focused mainly on arrests and prosecution. That may disrupt organisers, particularly where coercion is involved, but punishment alone does not address suicidal distress, online recruitment or the social isolation that makes absolute forms of belonging attractive. The humane distinction is between leaders suspected of pressuring people towards death and followers who may themselves be vulnerable or at risk.

Witchcraft accusations still harm minorities

Contemporary Iraqi interest in fortune-telling, sorcery and supernatural healing has periodically been described by journalists and civil-society organisations as increasing during years of insecurity. Reports have linked demand for practitioners with family conflict, illness, marriage difficulties, financial hardship and the desire for control in circumstances where institutions seem unable to help. Iraqi authorities have also treated some practitioners as fraudsters or sources of social harm.[The New Arab]newarab.comBelief in sorcery and supernatural on rise in IraqBelief in sorcery and supernatural on rise in Iraq

Such reporting should not be turned into a claim that Iraqi society is uniquely superstitious. Comparable practices exist across many countries, and the border between religious healing, folk custom, commercial fortune-telling and deliberate fraud is often contested. The more serious issue arises when witchcraft language is directed at a powerless population.

Sabean-Mandaeans, an indigenous religious minority with deep historical roots in Iraq, have repeatedly been stereotyped as impure, secretive or skilled in sorcery. European Union country guidance records accusations of witchcraft and sorcery as part of the discrimination they face, alongside extortion, land seizure and pressure to conform to dominant religious expectations. Minority Rights Group has similarly documented rhetoric accusing Mandaeans of witchcraft during the violence and displacement that followed the 2003 invasion.[European Union Agency for Asylum]euaa.europa.euEuropean Union Agency for Asylum3.10.4. Sabean-MandaeansEuropean Union Agency for Asylum3.10.4. Sabean-Mandaeans

Interviews with Mandaeans show how the stereotype operates in everyday life. A person may be approached not as a neighbour or fellow citizen but as someone presumed to know a “witch”, perform magic or belong to a polluted religion. What may appear to outsiders as a foolish superstition can help justify exclusion, harassment or seizure of property.[Kirkuk Now]kirkuknow.comOpen source on kirkuknow.com.

This is better understood as minority scapegoating than as a spontaneous mass delusion. The accusation attaches hidden power to a socially weak group: the minority is portrayed as secretly dangerous even while lacking the political or military strength to defend itself. Similar mechanisms appear in witchcraft accusations elsewhere, where claims of invisible harm transform prejudice into supposed self-protection.

Why fears spread so effectively

Iraq’s collective scares have varied greatly, but several pressures recur.

War weakened trusted sources of information. Decades of dictatorship, sanctions, invasion, insurgency and sectarian conflict damaged institutions and made secrecy, misinformation and sudden violence ordinary features of life. In such conditions, rumours about concealed plots can sound more credible because genuine conspiracies and armed networks also exist.

Sectarian competition gave prophecy political force. Claims about divinely chosen leaders or an approaching final struggle could challenge established clerics, mobilise followers and turn political disputes into sacred confrontations. The Najaf battle illustrates how theology, local power and wartime security became almost impossible to separate.

Visible outsiders provided easy targets. “Emo” youths could be identified by clothing, hair or behaviour. Mandaeans could be marked by religious identity and occupation. A panic spreads more easily when the supposed threat can be attached to recognisable bodies rather than an abstract problem.

Official language could legitimise fear. When a ministry described youth fashion as a social danger, or when security officials immediately framed an unclear battle as a foiled apocalyptic massacre, state authority shaped the story before independent evidence was available. Officials may sometimes be responding to genuine threats, but their words can also magnify them.

Social media accelerated newer movements. Online networks allow prophetic claims, rumours and emotionally charged videos to circulate without local clerical approval. They also let small groups appear larger than they are. Qurban belongs to a different media environment from the Soldiers of Heaven: recruitment and alarm can now cross provincial and national boundaries almost instantly.

None of these mechanisms requires Iraqis to be unusually credulous. They are recognisable responses to danger, uncertainty and weakened trust. The distinctive Iraqi pattern comes from the particular intensity of war, displacement, sectarian conflict and contested authority through which those ordinary human tendencies have operated.

What remains uncertain

Several popular stories about Iraq’s “cults and panics” are more definite in retelling than in the evidence.

The Soldiers of Heaven were real and armed, but accounts of their leadership, alliances and planned attack were inconsistent. The 2012 persecution of people labelled emo created genuine terror, but the often-repeated death figures were never firmly settled. Qurban has generated arrests and convictions, yet its true size and the full number of related deaths remain unclear. Reports of sorcery are widespread, but they do not prove a uniform national belief or a single organised occult movement.

There is also little strong evidence for a famous Iraqi equivalent of the European dancing plagues or a large, well-investigated school outbreak of mass psychogenic illness. Iraq’s most important cases belong instead to the histories of apocalyptic mobilisation, rumour, persecution and moral regulation.

Recognising uncertainty does not drain these stories of significance. It shifts attention to the most important question: not whether an entire population suddenly “went mad”, but how particular fears became believable, who had the power to define the threat, and who suffered once belief was translated into policy or violence.

Why these episodes still matter

Iraq’s history shows that collective belief can be both sincerely religious and politically useful, both personally meaningful and socially dangerous. Apocalyptic ideas helped some people interpret national catastrophe, but leaders could also use them to demand obedience or sacrifice. Concern about changing youth culture expressed real generational tension, but the language of Satanism turned difference into a licence for intimidation. Belief in harmful magic offered explanations for misfortune, yet accusations against Mandaeans reinforced persecution of an already vulnerable minority.

The most useful lesson is therefore not that Iraq has repeatedly succumbed to “mass hysteria”. It is that periods of fear make societies unusually receptive to stories that identify secret enemies and promise moral certainty. Those stories spread through institutions as well as crowds: ministries, militias, clerics, television channels, online networks and security agencies all help decide which claims become public reality.

Treating every unusual religious movement as a cult risks reproducing the panic being studied. Dismissing every supernatural belief as madness is equally misleading. A careful history asks separate questions about evidence, coercion, violence, social pressure and power. In Iraq, that approach reveals something more instructive than a collection of strange tales: it shows how people living through profound instability have searched for meaning, and how that search has sometimes been manipulated against them.

Amazon book picks

Further Reading

Books and field guides related to When Belief and Fear Became Public Threats. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.

Book

The Looming Tower

By Lawrence Wright

First published 2006. Subjects: Current Events, September 11 Terrorist Attacks, 2001, Qaida (Organization), Intelligence service, Nonfict...

See on Amazon

Book

Orientalism

By Edward W. Said

First published 1978. Subjects: Study and teaching, East and West, Foreign public opinion, Occidental, Imperialism, Foreign opinion, Occi...

See on Amazon

Book

The Shia Revival

By Vali Nasr

First published 2006. Subjects: Islam and politics, Sunnites, Middle east, politics and government, Shiites.

See on Amazon

Book

Black flags

By Joby Warrick

First published 2015. Subjects: Politics and government, POLITICAL SCIENCE / Political Freedom & Security / Terrorism, Islamic fundamenta...

See on Amazon

Browse more on Amazon:The Looming TowerOrientalismThe Shia Revival

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Endnotes

1. Source: brill.com
Link:https://brill.com/display/book/9789004214897/B9789004214897-s002.pdf?srsltid=AfmBOopzIKLPPrnpkuBJm2jWMytSJBvs5F7FhDmbIJ-RgbMHUyiCWeWK

2. Source: time.com
Title: how a cult grew in najaf
Link:https://time.com/archive/6940108/how-a-cult-grew-in-najaf/

3. Source: Wikipedia
Title: Soldiers of Heaven
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soldiers_of_Heaven

4. Source: Wikipedia
Title: Ahmed al-Hasan
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ahmed_al-Hasan

5. Source: Wikipedia
Title: Battle of Najaf (2007)
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Najaf_%282007%29

6. Source: arxiv.org
Title: arXiv#Failed Revolutions: Using Twitter to Study the Antecedents of ISIS Support
Link:https://arxiv.org/abs/1503.02401

7. Source: amnesty.org
Title: International Iraq: Investigate ‘Emo’ Attacks
Link:https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/press-release/2012/03/iraq-investigate-emo-attacks/

8. Source: Wikipedia
Title: 2012 emo killings in Iraq
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_emo_killings_in_Iraq

9. Source: en.964media.com
Title: Court sentences two men for membership in secretive
Link:https://en.964media.com/47712/

10. Source: Wikipedia
Title: Iranian schoolgirls mass poisoning
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_schoolgirls_mass_poisoning

11. Source: Wikipedia
Title: Satanic panic
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satanic_panic

12. Source: Wikipedia
Title: List of mass panic cases
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mass_panic_cases

13. Source: Wikipedia
Title: Witchcraft in the Middle East
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Witchcraft_in_the_Middle_East

14. Source: Wikipedia
Title: Allahiyah Movement
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allahiyah_Movement

15. Source: 2021-2025.state.gov
Link:https://2021-2025.state.gov/report/custom/a48a642035/

16. Source: 2021-2025.state.gov
Link:https://2021-2025.state.gov/report/custom/9ccc33e80c/

17. Source: oracc.museum.upenn.edu
Link:https://oracc.museum.upenn.edu/cmawro/corpus

18. Source: phil.uni-wuerzburg.de
Title: Philosophische Fakultät Tablets & Libraries
Link:https://www.phil.uni-wuerzburg.de/cmawro/magic-witchcraft/tablets-libraries/

19. Source: latimes.com
Title: Los Angeles Times Religious cult targeted in fierce battle near Najaf
Link:https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2007-jan-30-fg-messiah30-story.html

Published: January 30, 2007

20. Source: smallwarsjournal.com
Title: the untold story of the battle against the soldiers of heaven updated
Link:https://smallwarsjournal.com/2012/01/29/the-untold-story-of-the-battle-against-the-soldiers-of-heaven-updated/

21. Source: ctc.westpoint.edu
Link:https://ctc.westpoint.edu/iraq-as-the-focus-for-apocalyptic-scenarios/

22. Source: washingtonpost.com
Title: gIQAW9pD6R story
Link:https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/iraqi-youth-panicked-by-reports-of-killings/2012/03/11/gIQAW9pD6R_story.html

23. Source: middleeasteye.net
Title: iraq cracks down lottery based suicide cult has seen dozens deaths
Link:https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/iraq-cracks-down-lottery-based-suicide-cult-has-seen-dozens-deaths

24. Source: middleeastmonitor.com
Link:https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20240903-iraq-arrests-47-members-of-sect-that-encourages-suicide-to-increase-spirituality/

25. Source: newarab.com
Title: Belief in sorcery and supernatural on rise in Iraq
Link:https://www.newarab.com/society/2015/12/23/Belief-in-sorcery-and-supernatural-on-rise-in-Iraq

26. Source: euaa.europa.eu
Title: European Union Agency for Asylum3.10.4. Sabean-Mandaeans
Link:https://www.euaa.europa.eu/country-guidance-iraq-2024/3104-sabean-mandaeans

27. Source: kirkuknow.com
Link:https://www.kirkuknow.com/en/news/68966

28. Source: archive.org
Link:https://archive.org/details/corpusofmesopota0000unse

29. Source: euaa.europa.eu
Title: eu3.10.4. Sabean-Mandaeans
Link:https://www.euaa.europa.eu/print/pdf/node/24506

30. Source: newarab.com
Title: Iraqs witches and wizards crowd out doctors and psychiatrists
Link:https://www.newarab.com/society/2016/8/31/Iraqs-witches-and-wizards-crowd-out-doctors-and-psychiatrists

Additional References

31. Source: gtr.ukri.org
Title: Gt RCorpus of Mesopotamian Anti-Witchcraft Rituals, vol
Link:https://gtr.ukri.org/projects?ref=AH%2FG003777%2F1

32. Source: youtube.com
Title: Iraqi Sabean-Mandaeans celebrate marking “Banja” or Creation Feast
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KGU_pt0du1M

33. Source: books.google.com
Title: THE CORPUS OF ANCIENT MESOPOTAMIAN ANTIWITCHCRAFT RITUALS. 1.Read more
Link:https://books.google.com/books/about/Corpus_of_Mesopotamian_Anti_witchcraft_R.html?hl=en&id=85pTg4Zxp_YC

34. Source: youtube.com
Title: Iraq’s Mandaeans celebrate baptism feast
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TF_vKco3PHc

35. Source: academia.edu
Link:https://www.academia.edu/82304349/Corpus_of_Mesopotamian_Anti_witchcraft_Rituals

36. Source: researchgate.net
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/327820976_Millennialist_Narrative_and_Apocalyptic_Violence

37. Source: researchgate.net
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334571976_The_Corpus_of_Mesopotamian_Anti-Witchcraft_Rituals_Ancient_Mesopotamian_Witchcraft_Beliefs

38. Source: censamm.org
Link:https://censamm.org/resources/profiles/isis-islamic-apocalypticism

39. Source: ina.iq
Link:https://ina.iq/en/security/26547-fiia-arrests-what-so-called-al-qurban-group-in-dhi-qar.html

40. Source: trtworld.com
Link:https://www.trtworld.com/article/12796470